Thursday, November 5, 2015

Leon Auriol Open, 2015

Leon Auriol Open, 2015

https://askfred.net/Results/results.php?tournament_id=30720&highlight_competitor_id=91067&event_id=121121

This was my fourth Leon Auriol Open. They are always hard and I never do that well. But I enjoy them, mostly, and like watching the good fencers do their thing. My first time, in 2012, was my third tournament ever, and I lost quickly, but watched the rest. Daniel Small won. In 2013 it was much the same for me. Adam Frank won. Last year it was in our new space. The final was between Sam Larsen and Walter Dragonetti. Sam won by a point.

This year it was held at Rain City Fencing Center because our new space, in the same building, isn't ready for a bigger tournament. I had to leave before the semifinals so I missed the final bouts. The final was between Matthew Comes and Sam Larsen. Matthew won, despite the fact that the Portland fencers had apparently been studying and planning tactics to use with Matthew specifically. The winner has their name engraved on the trophy cup and I was thinking it likely that Sam would have his on there twice after this, but no! Matthew won by a comfortable 15-9.

About two weeks later, at the even harder Columbia Cup ROC in Portland, Sam and Matthew fenced again in the round of 8. That time Sam won handily, 15-4, and went on to take first place. Interesting how things can turn around like that. I should ask someone who was at both events if there were obvious differences in the way they fenced.

For me, well, I did not do very well in the pools. Not getting a bye, my first DE was with Maria Copelan. I thought I might be able to beat her. It began alright, but she adjusted her tactics and I didn't notice until it was too late and I was down on points. Then she adjusted again and basically doubled to end the bout. Either way though, the winner had to fence Matthew Comes, who was seed #2. I was hoping to get the chance, of course, but it was interesting to watch Maria fence him, and hear some of her teammates' coaching advice. Afterward, Erich Cranor talked to her about the bout and had many insightful comments. Smart fencers down there in Portland!

POOLS



My first pool bout was with a clubmate, of course. In the past that usually meant someone like Yuly. But this time it was with Dell Wolfensparger. This might be in part an effect of my being a C now (Dell is a U). But it was also in part luck. The A in my pool was Erich Cranor. Clubmates were mostly split up among the pools, but George and Russ shared a pool, as did Jim and Yuly, and other combinations of mixed ratings. So it was lucky that my first bout wasn't with George, or any number of other possibilities. I figured I should be able to beat Dell, "maybe even 5-0" I thought to myself. I probably shouldn't indulge thoughts like that, they usually lead to trouble. Dell fenced his best, hard and strong, right from the start. I had my usual first bout slowness. Fairly quickly he was up two points to my one. I managed to tie it at 2-2. Then I made a mental adjustment, increasing my focus and determination. I had started sloppy and a little stupid. So I cleared my mind and focused more on the moment-to-moment fencing. And I increased my pacing, patience, and defense. Instead of making risky attacks like I had at first, I worked on drawing attacks with feints and distance stuff. It worked. Dell obliged me by attacking into my feints or from too far. I got the rest of the touches, winning 5-2.

I considered that a kind of warm-up bout. It took me a couple touches to find the right mindset. But I had found it, I figured, and things would go smoother. My next bout, however, was with Erich Cranor. He's a tall, left-handed, A-rated fencer from Portland. He's a vet, and maybe a little slower than he might have been once. But he is far from slow, and he is a very smart fencer. Plus did I mention he is tall and left-handed? Argh. I remembered doing fairly well against him last year at the Columbia Cup vet event. So I drew on that for ideas. I remember getting him on the knee, which he tends to stick out a bit. And also scoring with a duck under one of his high fleches (did I say he is tall?). I also remembered his good flicks and outside attacks. So my plan was to protect my outside line and arm in general, to look for low line openings, and be ready for fleches I could duck.

I lost 5-0, ouch. So much for the plan? Maybe not. There were two or three touches that were very close. Had things gone just slightly different I might have done fairly well. I think I underestimated his reach and got too close. And my ducking plan did not work, maybe because I began to duck a few times when I thought he was about to fleche but didn't. Perhaps he noticed, so when I did duck his fleche he made sure not to go too high. Anyway, losing 5-0 was a bummer and maybe effected my fencing afterwards.

Next up I had Fynn Mansbridge-Fafard, a Canadian from the Dynamo club. I don't think I had fenced him before, or even seen him really. I lost 5-3. I don't remember the details now, writing this about a month later. In my notebook I just wrote "bleah". Fynn ended up coming in 6th overall, getting a C rating (he was a D).

Then I had Benjamin Duchow. There's a bunch of Duchow fencers, and the name scares me a little. Some of them are very good. Henry Duchow has beaten me a few times, if I recall right. Benjamin is a younger sibling, I think. Again I don't remember the details now, and didn't write notes. But I ended up winning 5-3. This helped boost my confidence. I was two and two, which wasn't so bad. And I had Mark Benack still to fence, who I should be able to beat, right?

I knew I shouldn't think I should be able to beat anyone, since it messes with my head so much. I did my best to put such thoughts out of my mind and went into the bout with Mark Benack with decent focus. It turned out to be a close bout, mostly tied. I got the first point with a pick to his hand as he lifted it for a flick. That felt good. Maybe it made me a little too confident. I made some ill-advised attacks. Once or twice I tried to coax him into distance and then fleche, but he got me with a prime parry and a crazy flexible riposte to my back. The score reached 4-4. We were both fairly cautious. I tried, again, to set up a distance trap. Eventually it worked and he stepped in a little too much. I launched a surprise fleche as he stepped and had it, except I missed! My point went over his shoulder and he had an easy counterattack point to win, 5-4. Alas. Woe. Fun bout though.

My last pool bout was with Aaron Page. The last time we fenced was in a DE at BladeFest vets. It was tough, but I had won. I had used a lot of point-up hand invitations coupled with hard beats, and we had talked about it afterward. He had clearly thought about this tactic of mine and had come up with some ideas about countering it. So this time I thought it might be wise to do something else entirely. I figured he would expect similar tactics (and I think he said he was, more or less, afterward), so perhaps I could throw him off by doing totally different things. Also, I was having epee trouble and both my LPs were out at this point. I had the choice of either using my relatively stiff Absolute epee, or the more flicky Vniti. Normally I would use the Absolute, especially if I planned to use lots of beats like I had with Aaron at BladeFest. But because I was thinking of using different tactics I decided to use the Vniti. And because the Vniti is flicky I thought I would focus on flicky things.

The plan was to avoid his blade, draw attacks, then land flicks on his arm one way or another. Well, it wasn't what he expected, apparently, but it didn't work either. He won 5-1.

DIRECT ELIMINATION

So I came out of the pools two and four, with a -7 indicator, making me 34th seed out of 47. There were a good number of byes, so I got a first round DE with Maria Copelan, who was 30th seed. We had fenced once, long ago now, in a pool bout. I had won that time, but probably more out of sheer energy than good form or tactics. At one point I had chased her down the whole strip, somehow actually scoring at the end. I've seen her fence a number of times since then, including at Nationals, and felt like I had a decent sense of her style. It was funny how, before we fenced, she introduced herself to me and I felt like saying "oh, I know who you are!" Well, I did say something like that, but a little nicer, I hope.

The key to her style, I thought, was that she likes to fleche. If I could draw her fleche while ready to quickly retreat I thought I would have a decent chance to score. In other regards, I am taller, and maybe could get some shallow target hits. Or at least I could threaten shallow targets as part of drawing fleches.

The bout began more or less as I had planned. I used threats and feints and shallow attacks and she fleched a lot. I retreated as best I could when she fleched and was able to score or at least get a double touch most of the time. I got up a few points. Then she changed tactics and I didn't notice (she told me afterward). She realized her fleches were not going to do it. She stopped fleching and concentrated on a more defensive, shallow-target thing. Not realizing, I continued my own shallow threats and feints, which gave her opportunities to score. Actually I don't remember quite how she scored during this part of the bout. I think I was a little stuck in my "draw her fleche" mindset. She tied the score, then got up two or three points.

Around that point I finally began to realize that something had changed, although I wasn't sure what. Not being sure, and now being down on points, I grew more cautious and probably hesitant. And at this point, once she was up a few points, she changed again. She started fleching again, figuring (she said afterwards) she could double out and win. And that's pretty much what happened. She got a bunch of fleching double touches. Maybe my hesitancy at this point worked against me and I was more easily surprised by her fleches. In any case, once she was up on points and started fleching again she won pretty quickly. The final score was 15-11.

In hindsight, and after talking to her a little, I learned some useful things—especially about my not noticing her changes in tactics as the bout progressed. It is good to have a plan, especially if it is working. But it is important to watch for tactical shifts. If a plan is working a smart opponent will try to come up with ways to adjust. I should not get stuck in a plan, and should watch even more closely for changes when things are working well. And the same thing the other way. If the balance of points changes, it is possible that a smart fencer will adjust tactics then too. It is tricky seeing tactical changes like this, and making them myself, but it is one of the things I like the most about fencing tournaments these days.

After beating me Maria fenced Matthew Comes. She lost, but did alright, 15-10. Afterward she and Erich talked a little about what happened. I was nearby and heard some of it. They had made plans for Matthew specifically, apparently studying videos of him, or at least talking about his tactics. One thing they had worked on was Matthew's ducks. A few times Matthew had successfully ducked Maria's fleches. Talking with Erich she seemed to know she had miscalculated in those cases. But she said, in a somewhat flummoxed way, that Matthew had used ducks offensively, which she didn't expect. It was interesting hearing Erich's response. He said no, they were not offensive ducks, but rather than tell her what he thought he instead asked her a series of questions that led her to the conclusion he had in mind. In short, Matthew had used an aggressive advancing move followed immediately with a ducking extension. While advancing he made blade motions that cleverly looked inviting but not obviously so. Maria had fleched into this, and thus right into Matthew's duck. Had she not fleched, nothing would have happened. So it wasn't an "offensive duck". Maybe you could call it a counter-offensive duck, I don't know. I tried it myself a bit in practice after this, but I can't duck nearly as well as Matthew. Alas, I'm a lot older. On the other hand, at least I can duck at all. Many people my age don't, or can't.

After watching Maria and Matthew, I watched a bit more before having to go. I saw Sam take out Shawn Dodge. Sam seemed to be in excellent form and I left expecting him to win first place. I watched Yuly beat Andrew Lee in a very close 15-14 bout. Then Yuly had Matthew. I had seen them fence quite a few times and had to go anyway, so I left. Matthew won, 15-13, and went on to win the whole thing.

BladeFest Div2 Senior Men's Epee

BladeFest Div2 Senior Men's Epee

https://askfred.net/Results/results.php?tournament_id=30135&highlight_competitor_id=91067&event_id=118400

I've put off writing about this for far too long. And I just realized I lost my old notebook in which I scribbled notes during the event, oops. Well, I didn't write much and wasn't going to post much here. I was hoping to do better, since I could have qualified for div2 if I did well. I'm not sure how that works exactly. I came in 14th out of 28, which I doubt got me qualified.

I went two and four in the pools and felt generally slow and off. I lost badly to Charlie Muñoz, 1-5, ouch! Tobias Lee was in my pool and I looked forward to seeing if I could do better than I had in the past, but alas, I lost 2-5. I also lost to Mark Benack, 3-5. He's getting better and better. I had a close bout with Svetoslav Dimitrov, losing 4-5. So I came in next to last in my pool.



So I was 20th seed. In the DEs I got paired with Charlie, who was 12th seed. Yay, a clubmate in DEs (sarcasm). We had a great bout, the high point of the day for me. I was mostly a bit behind but came back at the end to win 15-13. I felt bad for Charlie, but good about adjusting my tactics and figuring out something that worked at the end.

My second DE was Audun Holland-Goon, who I've always had trouble with and, as time goes by, have increasing trouble with. Sure enough, he beat me, 15-10.

Saturday, October 24, 2015

A couple gifs

Will have more AAR ("after action reports", right?) soon, really! In the meantime, I learned how to make GIFs, so here's a few.

Hmm, I don't know if blogger can show gifs very well, or they load super slow. So, just links for now. See if I can figure it out better. I think I made them embedded. May be they are just slow to load. Still testing.






Wednesday, September 2, 2015

BladeFest 2015, Vet Epee, and gold

BladeFest 2015, Vet Epee

https://askfred.net/Results/results.php?tournament_id=30135&highlight_competitor_id=91067&event_id=118403#118403

Since Nationals at least I've been slow in writing up these "after action reports". Maybe because it's summer. It seems best when I do it just after a tournament—like right after. If a few days pass it easily becomes a few weeks. Immediately after BladeFest there was a lot of summer and kid related stuff going on, so it has taken a while. Let's see what I can still remember.

Well, the awesome thing was coming in first place. I've been wanting to come in first place for a long time. I didn't care what kind of tournament, any kind would do. An E and under with only six fencers, sure, whatever. I've come in second place twice (both in U only tournaments, but still), and third place at least five times. I wanted to come in first someday, if only to see what it feels like.



After Nationals my tournament goals were basically to get a D rating and to come in first in something, anything. So it was funny that in the very first tournament after Nationals, the Subway Games, I got a C, and then in the next tournament, BladeFest Vet, I came in first. Well. Time for new goals.

Actually, I figured those goals were basically "things that would be nice". I don't think moving up the ratings is a very good goal, since there is so much random chance involved. And coming in first, yea, it wasn't something I was consciously aiming for—more an "it would be nice" thing. My "real" goals have more to do with specific "getting better at fencing" things—improving my balance, less shoulder tension, better parries, etc. Then again, these are goals that don't really have an end point.

Anyway, coming in first was nice. And it wasn't as small or easy a tournament as it could have been—I had to win four DEs. In other tournaments I've won several DEs but always lost one in the end, of course. To continue winning until there is "no one left" felt very nice, I must say.

POOLS

There were 18 fencers, so three pools of six. Throughout I felt a bit off, uncertain, a little slow and unfocused.



First I fenced Robert Lampson. We hadn't fenced in a long time. I remember fencing him in a pool at...the Battle in Seattle? And winning, but it was close. I remembered using strong beats against his French grip style, but also having some lucky touches. He was using a French grip again, I think, so I went in with the idea of trying to draw attacks or at least blade extensions, then using hard beats. Things didn't go quite like I hoped. He was faster on his feet than I expected, and I felt slow and uncertain, like I often do in a first pool bout.

He got the first two points, the second one a nice toe touch that surprised me. Then I got one, somehow, and another with, finally, a hard beat and fleche. Then he got the next two. I think I kept inching a little too close, trying to draw him out. I wanted to draw him out in ways I could beat or parry, but instead he just hit me. Or I would try a strong beat but he'd get his point back in line fast, or evade my beat. Maybe my actions were too obvious.

At 4-2 I started to get a little more focused and got a single. Then we ended up a little tangled and close, and he hit my shin, I think. Afterward he said that last one was lucky. Maybe, but he probably would have won one way or another.

Then I had Jeff Lucas, who has been getting a lot better lately and almost won—should have won even. I've forgotten how things began, but I think we were tied 2-2 and he got a nice outside hand hit, making it 3-2. Then, if I remember right, we doubled, making it 4-3. That got me trying to be very careful. Doubles would not do. I took my time trying to find an opening and, luckily, he launched a fleche from too far, basically giving me a point and making it 4-4. I don't remember the details of the last point, except that it was close either way. I got it and won, 5-4, but it was very nearly his. Could have gone either way. Yikes.

Third up was Jeff Johnson. I felt like I knew what I should do with him. We had practice fenced a bit in July and discussed what worked or didn't work against each other. And I had watched him and seen how his main tactics work. Of course he had fenced me and knew what my tactics were too, particularly my tactics against him. So it wasn't surprising when he did a good job denying me opportunities to do the things I wanted to—mainly strong beats against his French grip and drawing him into attacking. He very patiently waited me out, keeping his blade back and out so I couldn't beat, and tempting me to go for his inside hand, arm, or body. I did my best to feint and draw his attack, but he was good about not biting until I was truly committed to a real attack. Then he would get my arm on the outside, as expected.

Still, I managed one nice inside hand pick and kept the score fairly close. We tied 2-2, then he got up a point and we essentially doubled our way to my 5-4 loss. Toward the the end time was running out. I kept trying to get him to attack and he patiently waited, content with his lead and defense. My last attempts to tie came in the last few seconds of the bout.

There was an odd bit where we had a mild corps-a-corps and the ref gave Jeff a yellow card. Jeff asked why and he said "corps-a-corps", which was confusing. It might have made sense for jostling or something, although it had been a mild and clearly unintentional corps-a-corps. Jeff almost let it pass, it just being a yellow card, but asked for further clarification. After a bit of confusion the ref apologized and said he was mistaken, no card. [edit: just realized it is "corps-a-corps" not "corp-a-corp"; silly French]

After Jeff I was one and two, not where I had hoped to be. Next up was Brent Farnsworth, who I figured I should be able to beat, but then I had figured my bout with Jeff wouldn't have been as close, and that I should have done better with Jeff and Robert. I have to stop thinking I "should" or "shouldn't" be able to do things! But, perhaps by this point I was getting more in the right headspace. I did well and won 5-1. I don't remember the details, although I think I was starting to use this Max Heinzer-inspired thing involving a tip-up guard, inviting hand hit attempts, coupled with extra-strong seconde beat/smacks, followed by either sixte oppositions or, failing that, sixte-prime type stuff. I used this kind of stuff quite a lot in the DEs with decent results.

Anyway, all I remember with Brent is getting one weird hit on his back while passing him in a fleche...or while he was passing me. And one time I fleched and missed, letting him score.

Next up, and last, was Dreas Nielsen, a newish (I think) WFA fencer. We had warmed up a little together, but otherwise I don't think we had fenced before. Our bout was fairly ugly and I felt like I was awkward. One time I charged badly in a kind of half-hearted fleche that abruptly stopped right in front of him. I got stuck and he scored. Otherwise I did okay, if somewhat awkward, and ended up winning 5-3.

I came out three and two with an indicator of +4, which got me third place in my pool. Both Jeff Johnson and Robert Lampson won all their bouts but one (Robert lost to Jeff and Jeff lost to Brent). Jeff had a +11 indicator and easily took first in the pool, and 3rd seed overall. Carlo Malaguzzi also went four and one in his pool, with a +15 indicator, so got 2nd seed. Mark Blom won all five pool bouts and got 1st seed. I tied with Joel Howard for 7th seed. I worried that this would not be high enough to get far in the DEs.

DIRECT ELIMINATION

I was thinking BladeFest was a Div 2 tournament, so everyone was a C or under, except Frank Hewitt, a B. I wasn't sure why Frank was in a Div 2 tournament but figured there was some reason. Later I learned that the vet event was not limited to Div 2. I was lucky, I guess, that no one like John Varney was there. Still, I had to laugh when I saw that my first DE was with Frank Hewitt, the sole B fencer.

I've learned to ignore ratings, but I couldn't help but notice that he was the only B, and everyone else was a C or less. Also, I don't think I have fenced Frank before. Or if I have I couldn't remember. Don told me a bit about him. Apparently he is on the US World Vet team, which scared me, but in the over 70 category, which made me a little less scared—though not much. Don warned me about Frank's excellent bladework and point control. I went in feeling concerned and nervous. But things went very well and I won fairly easily, in one period and a decent lead the whole time.

I mainly stuck with shallow actions and lots of disruptive blade actions, beating his blade and trying to break up anything he might try to set up, while looking for shallow opportunities and trying to stay threatening. I used that "Heinzer" thing a lot and it seemed to work pretty well. I'd do hard swats in seconde which would sometimes surprise and "freeze" him for a moment, and sometimes would get him to launch an attack, perhaps because my blade would go far outside, but I could return to sixte quickly. I'm calling this stuff "Heinzer" for lack of any other name, but I'm sure it isn't at all like what Heinzer was actually doing in the video I got the ideas from. Actually, maybe I should call it "seconde swat". I don't know.

In that video Heinzer kept using a guard with his tip way up, making a very blatant invitation to his lower hand. It was way too blatant an invitation for anyone to fall for, not at Heinzer's level. I'm not sure what the point was for him. But from this position he would make very strong "swats" into seconde, sometimes onto the other person's blade, sometimes not. Again I'm not sure what this means at his level. Then, sometimes, he fleched out of the seconde swat, sometimes with opposition in sixte, sometimes in octave. It wasn't exactly clear to me, but it looked cool enough for me to try out in rough imitation a bit in practice. And I had figured out a few possible things to do with this "seconde swat" thing. I suspect one of the key things for me was the surprise of how strong a swat I can do, especially from that tip-up guard position. Thwacking the blade far out of line might trigger a bit of panic. Also, my own blade goes rather far out of line with these swats, and sometimes I would throw out one that intentionally missed the other person's blade, with the goal of drawing an attack.

(Actually, I just remembered Leland Guillemin posted a gif of Heinzer a month or two ago, showing an example of this move: http://www.gfycat.com/GranularHauntingGalapagosalbatross —this gif was the seed of my trying "seconde swats", although I highly doubt what I do is anything at all like what Heinzer does! Leland describes it a bit in this reddit post, https://www.reddit.com/r/Fencing/comments/395mbp/one_of_my_favourite_max_heinzer_touches_from_the/ — he calls it an 8-6 fleche and "one of Heinzer's patented moves". While Leland calls it an "8" it looks more like a 2 to me.)

I wasn't really sure about most of this, and still am not, but writing now I think another key aspect of this swat tactic is to draw attacks—by getting so far out of line maybe I look vulnerable to a high line attack. So I'd swat and if the other person attacked I'd quickly return to sixte, and if that didn't catch their blade (ie, they disengaged to the inside), prime. I suspect this whole thing is a tactic of limited long-term value. A couple days later Aaron Page said he had worked out some ways to deal with it, for example. But also, it seems like the kind of tactic that depends on surprise. Surprise by the strong swat, and surprise by the apparently high line opening. If I use it enough for someone to get used to it they are bound to work out ways to deal with it, or at least not to attack into it. So I'm already kind of giving it up. Also, the strength of the swat makes me reluctant to do it very much in practice, where against most people it feels somewhat rude. In tournaments though...

Anyway, I won my first DE, yay. Next I was paired with 2nd seed Carlo Malaguzzi, which made me shake my head. We've fenced quite a bit over the years and he usually beats me, often badly. But lately I feel like I have begun to figure out what might work with him, and what definitely does not work. Mainly I seem to have trouble with his binds and beats, especially his binding fleches. I get in trouble if I let him take my blade, especially if I also give him time to set things up. In other words, in the past I learned that if make strong/deep attacks, he parries well and hits me. If I wait for him to attack he sets up lovely fleches with beats or binds. Seen that way I needed to avoid making big attacks but prevent him for setting up his own attacks.

So I went in with a few basic tactical ideas. I would use absence of blade so he would have trouble beating or binding. And I would try to break up his prep with my own beats and with footwork, in and out, broken up. Also I would try to stay shallow and defensive. I get in trouble when I fleche him.

That was the basic idea, and it worked well. I used absence of blade in both down and up positions—sort of like Dragonetti does (or Heinzer in that gif, though I was "more absent" than that). The upward absence position was just right for starting that seconde swat, so I threw that out a lot. I mostly scored by counterattacking. His attacks were easier to deal with from an absence of blade position, since I still have a lot of trouble when he beats and binds me. When I attacked we mostly doubled—he'd parry me and hit on the riposte, while I would usually just manage to escape his parry in time to double. I soon gave up attacking. Once I was up a few points everything seemed easier. I was happy to wait and did well with counterattacking. As I got up more he was forced to attack more. I won 10-5. Afterward Jeff Lucas said it looked "decisive". Carlo, Jeff, and I went out to eat after the event and I learned that Carlo wasn't feeling 100%—his knee, or ankle, or something, was not feeling great, which was throwing him off. That undoubtedly helped me be "decisive".

Next up was Aaron Page in a semifinal bout. I had made it to at least third place. I looked forward to this one. It feels like sometimes Aaron just destroys me, but other times he seems off and I do well. I don't think we had had a DE bout before. In any case it was the hardest DE bout for me. It was close most of the way. I got up a point or two, then he came back. I think we tied 8-8, then I got the last two points to win.

My tactics were similar to what I did with Carlo. I tried to stay shallow and avoid deep attacks, feeling daunted by Aaron's parries. So I tried staying shallow and using lots of disruptive bladework, especially those seconde swats. Afterward Aaron called them "traps", which I guess they are, even if I hadn't worked it out in my head very well. He said he kept trying to evade my swats and hit my hand, but couldn't quite get it to work. Thinking about that action now it does seem like a trap, or a double trap even. At first it's a blatant invitation/trap, with my hand exposed from below. Then the swat opens my hand up from above. The first invitation is too blatant to work, unless I get stupidly close. The second one though. Maybe if done well it can look like I am not meaning to expose my hand like that. I think at the time I half meant the swat as a trap and half didn't really understand what I was doing, which perhaps made it more convincing and less blatant.

Anyway, I think I got a few points out of the seconde swat trap thing, or at least broke things up and distracted him. A couple times he fleched from too far, which I was happy to take advantage of. The last point, I was up 9-8 but for some reason ended up attacking with a fleche. I got parried but managed to escape and, passing, landed a hit on his knee. It was a bit awkward and lucky. But I'll take it.

The final bout was with Mark Blom, who had won all his DEs rather decisively (10-3 in all three). I had watched some of his bouts and seen people falling for his leftie French-grip tactics. I felt like I had fenced him enough to know basically what to expect and what to do. I needed to protect my outside, watch out for his surprise toe and low line attacks, and try to use a lot of beats if I could.

So, mainly, beats, attempt to draw attacks, stay shallow. Twice I tried a beat and attack to the body inside, and both times he recovered from the beat in time to hit my arm outside. Don, who coached me in the breaks, told me to stay outside and shallow. That going for the body was not going to work well. And that protecting the outside might mean way outside, as Mark sometimes gets way out there and angulates to the arm, getting around a "normal" parry six. Something like that.

So I stopped trying to go deep and worked more on the outside line. I found I was able to stop some of his outside attacks with what felt like really wide parry sixes.  I had trouble scoring from that position, but at least I stopped him a bit. I got one point simply by keeping my bell guard at his point, so that his attack got deflected by my guard just enough to miss, while my point just nicked his arm. That one surprised me a little and I didn't quite understand it. In a break Don explained it and after I kept trying to put my bell guard in the way of his point.

I got at least two points with a kind of high six beat followed by a prime-like lunge. Mark's blade was often way over in "my six", what with him being left-handed and tending to hold his blade outside and sometimes a bit point-up absence-ish. So sometimes I could make a strong sweeping beat into six and then lunge to his inside, turning my hand over and moving my arm away in a somewhat prime-like way. Sometimes, I think, I was able to capture his blade in six this way and transfer it to prime, so his blade would be caught behind my guard.

Anyway, I won 10-8—the same score as with Aaron Page, but I think I kept up a better lead than I had with Aaron. I felt fairly well in control. I made a few mistakes but corrected them (with some help from Don), and felt like I adjusted to things pretty well.

All in all it felt really nice to come in first. It also got me a C rating for the second time, making me feel like I really deserved it, even if ratings are best ignored and mean a lot less than they seem to. Also, it was interesting to see how I moved from feeling slow, uncertain, and not well focused in the pools, to much more focused and confident in the DEs. Where I felt a bit distracted in the pools and thought too much about bigger picture things, in the DEs I felt much more able to focus on "one touch at a time", with minimal distraction about the score. Maybe in part it has to do with the fact that if a DE is lost then you are finished fencing. I don't want to be finished fencing, so I work harder in the DEs?

Toby took some photos. Thanks Toby!

I score on Carlo, I guess he missed.


Carlo scores on me. This one showcases some bad form on my part, ugh.


Aaron and me.


Aaron and me from the other direction.


Apparently I scored on Mark Blom here, despite the awkward form. Perhaps a double touch.


This and the following are nice, showing me and Mark and the "six-ish to prime-ish" thing. Here the six-ish part, although looking now, unsure if "six" is at all the right term.

And the prime-ish lunge.


Gold!





Tuesday, July 28, 2015

2015 Subway Washington Games and a C

2015 Subway Washington Games

https://askfred.net/Results/results.php?tournament_id=30002&highlight_competitor_id=91067&event_id=117858

A good one! I came in 7th out of 32 and earned my C, skipping right over that D. Well, I was thinking it was only a matter of time before I earned a new rating, although I didn't think I would jump to C. To some degree I was thinking a D would be nice but maybe not a C yet, because it takes me out of Div3 events. I really enjoyed Div3 at Nationals. And maybe a third of the local tournaments around here are D and under, or E and under. So now I have fewer to go to, unless I travel more. Not that I'm complaining—it felt good to do well at this tournament. It was the first tournament after Nationals and I think I was able to tap into the same kind of focus and confidence I had there. After feeling some frustration with my fencing around last winter I feel like I have reached some kind of new plateau. Not that there are not still a million things I am trying to get better at, and probably a million more I am not even aware of but should be.

POOLS



My first bout was against my clubmate Yuly Suvorov. A difficult start! We tied 1-1, then it went downhill and I lost 2-5. No big surprise there.

Second bout was with Jazzy Shepard, one of the people who had come up from Northpointe Fencing, apparently with the Meehan clan. I had difficulty but managed to get to 4-4. Then we had two or three doubles, ack. Then I got the last point and won 5-4, but I think there was some luck involved in it.

Next up was Isobel Fife, another Northpointe fencer I had never met. I won 5-2. I felt rather awkward and too often out of balance, getting scrappy points. Not pretty, but okay.

Then I had John Comes, who is always fun. I was unsure how it would go, but it quickly went well for me. I got up 3-1, then we doubled 4-2. I think I mostly scored by taking advantage of little mistakes on his part. Once I think he made an overly large parry. Another time I think I caught his attack up in six. At 4-2 I apparently got cocky, and/or he got more focused. I figured all I needed was a double, but he got a single, 4-3, then another, 4-4, uh oh. I tried to turn up the intensity and try to trigger mistakes. I don't remember exactly how it happened, but I think he slightly overreacted to a feint and I circled under his parry and scored with a low fleche. So another 5-4 win, phew.

My last bout was with B.J. Block, a fencer I didn't know, from Dynamo in Canada. I forget the exact details, but I felt pretty confident and used distance work to lure him too close or attack from too far. I won 5-3.

So, a decent pool. Four and two, with an indicator of +4, making my 2nd place in the pool and 9th seed overall.

DIRECT ELIMINATION

There were exactly 32 of us, so no byes at all. As 9th seed I was paired with 24th seed Abby Barr. I think we've fenced a couple times before, and I think she beat me in a pool some time back. She has nice form and good parries, although I had a definite height advantage. As I've been doing lately, I tried to keep the first period score low, mostly testing things out. I saw some openings early on and took them, getting a 3-1 lead. But then she scored on my hand, we doubled, and she scored again on my hand. So the period ended 4-3. Russ told me to keep my bell guard lower, to counter her lower hand picks. He also suggested I could be more aggressive, using my height advantage and pushing the attack more. These things worked well and the second period ended 12-8, a comfortable place. Russ repeated that I could push the attack more. So in the third period I did, and it didn't take long to score three singles, winning 15-8.

Looking at the DE tableau I saw my second DE would be against the winner of a bout between Aaron Page and Svetoslav Dimitrov. Aaron had seeded much higher and I thought it likely I would have to fence him. But then I saw him taking his jacket off and went over to ask him about it. He had lost, so I'd be fencing Svetoslav. Aaron said he felt like he should have won, but had been out late the night before and, while his fencing mind could see what should be done, his body hadn't been willing. He told me I should do fine, and that Svetoslav tends to fleche a lot, but in a fairly straightforward way that I should be able to deal with.

So I went into my second DE, with Svetoslav Dimitrov, with a basic plan of working the distance and triggering fleches from too far. I was cautious in the first period, and he seemed reluctant to fleche, even when I pushed him back to his end of the strip. We basically traded points, ending the period 6-6. In the second period he got up a point but then I tied it and then got up a point myself. Once I was up he seemed more eager to fleche, and I did whatever I could to trigger it. Usually I could double or single off his fleches. The second period ended 12-10. In the third period started off more cautious and I was happy to fence patiently, trying to trigger attacks and generally being defensive. In the first two minutes not much scoring happened. With about a minute to go he began to attack more, generally to my benefit. As time got down to about twenty seconds his clubmates began to warn him and I got ready for attacks. At some point the score was 13-11 I think and as we came on guard with not a lot of time it seemed obvious that he was going to attack rather quickly. I had been mostly defensive, but at that point I figured I might be able to surprise him, so I advance-lunged off the time, right into the start of his fleche, scoring a single and getting me to 14. The final point was another quick fleche of his, which I doubled out on, winning 15-13.

I wasn't thinking about the bigger picture. I took the slip to the bout committee and got a drink, then was surprised when Yuly said "welcome to C land", or something to that effect. I was surprised, a C, really? He said "well, you're in the final 8, so yes". I was quite surprised. He also pointed out I had him for my next DE. There was some talk about how if I beat Yuly I would get a B. I laughed at how unlikely that was, and how I was barely ready to be a C, let alone a B. "Not that I won't try", I said.

So my third DE was with Yuly Suvorov, and although I lost I was happy to have put up a good fight and made him work for the win. I didn't write notes about the score, but I think I kept it close to tied up to about 6-6. He was usually up a point or two, and pulled a bit more ahead toward the end. He won 15-11.

All in all, a good day! Goodbye Div 3.


Sunday, July 26, 2015

2015 Nationals Div 3 Epee

2015 Nationals Div 3 Epee

http://usfencingresults.org/results/2014-2015/2015.06-JUN-SN/FTEvent_2015Jun27_DV3ME.htm

A super fun pool in which I did well and felt very confident. Then I won my first DE with a comfortable lead, slightly eroded in the end (I was glad to have a few points to spare for mistakes). Lost my second DE but felt like I fenced well enough and could have won had things gone a little differently, or if I could fence this guy again, having learned about his style.

The day before I browsed the vendors and got new knickers—Leon Paul Phoenix level. This div3 event was the first time I fenced in them and they felt soooo much better than the cheap, old Blue Gauntlet knickers I had been using. I think I fenced better with them. I had come to hate my old ones, and wearing these made me really really hate them. Glad to be rid of them. Of course the new ones are so brilliantly white my jacket looks grey. I tried on the LP Phoenix jacket and it felt very nice. But one thing at a time. Plus I only just got my name put on my jacket!



I was in pool #16, on strip D4. As in vet40 I had a couple friends in my pod. Shawn Dodge was on strip D2 and Jeff Johnson was on D3. In the DEs I stayed in the D pod with Jeff, joined by Kyle Margolies. Shawn went to another pod for his DEs. Luckily I didn't have to fence any of them. I joked that if Kyle and I had to fence a DE I was going to complain to someone.

As with the vet40 event I didn't take notes and so don't have much of a play-by-play. I wrote down some basic stuff a day or two later, but this may be a minimal report.

POOLS



My first bout was with Eugene Vinitsky and I lost badly, 1-5. My sister and I kinda came up with nicknames or identifying qualities of most of the fencers in my pool. Eugene, we agreed, was just very happy. He was very nice, chatty, and seemed just thrilled about being there and everything that was happening. Which was much like I felt, really (my "nicknames" I used in my notes to remember better included happy, bear, leftie, and bouncy). Overall Eugene did well, going four and two like me, but with a slightly higher indicator. Later in the pool we talked and he said I was doing well, and that he thought maybe he was lucky to have fenced me first. And yes, I suspect I would have done better against him later in the pool. But then maybe I would have had trouble with whoever I fenced first. Anyway, Eugene took 2nd place in our pool (I came in 3rd).

My second bout was with Joseph Chong, and I won 5-1, turning around that first 1-5 loss. I think I scored almost entirely by working the distance and waiting for him to step just a little too close. From that point on I felt more and more confident. And working the distance was my main tactic. Throughout the pool Russ kept telling me to stay active, "in and out". Mostly I'd start with quick aggressive forward footwork, then fall back into a long, slow retreating pattern, all mixed up with threats, body feints, and such—trying to draw attacks from too far and/or lure people in too close. Mostly it worked quite well, I think. Everyone in my pool was a lot younger than me. They were decent enough, but I think my sense of distance was better, mostly.

My next bout was with Myles Bear. We had a closer bout. I think we went 4-4 and I squeaked out the last point to win 5-4. Later Myles told me he was mainly a foilist and had only really tried epee at the qualifying tournament, where he did well enough to qualify and earn a D in epee. I think my sister was rooting for him in the pool a little, maybe thinking it funny that there was a bear and a fly in the pool. He did okay, coming out 5th.

Next I had Addison Wessel, a leftie who did well, coming in first place in our pool. I was the only one who beat him, 5-3. It felt fairly straightforward, mostly about distance. Although at one point, when I was up a point or two, I remembered Charlie's leftie flick to the hand thing. The last time this tactic popped into my head and I tried it Jeff Johnson pegged me in the shoulder. I've since been practicing it a little more and getting a better feel for the right distance required (and I've also come to learn how and why it isn't the best thing to try with Jeff). Anyway, it popped into my head and I took a moment to set the distance right, then threw it out. It worked perfectly. A lovely flick right to his inside hand. That felt nice.

Then I had Albert Aboaf, who my sister had dubbed "bouncy", as he sometimes broke into really fast bouncing forward and back. My luring into distance ploy worked quite well with him, and I won 5-2. Albert ended up coming in 6th in our pool.

Last I had Jonas Kulberg-Savercool, who ended up coming in last in our pool. He had lost every bout. A couple were close, 5-4, but three were not—a couple 5-1 and a 5-2. So I am not sure why I lost to him, 5-3. I think I was feeling a little too cocky, and perhaps a little tired. I did some stupid things, and made some mistakes. Oops.

I was still quite happy coming out four and two, with a +4 indicator. My preliminary seeding was 112 out of 145. After the pools my seed was a tie for 46. In the end I finished 48th out of 145.

DIRECT ELIMINATION

My first DE was with David Mackenzie. The way the pod was being run we were told to sit "on deck" and wait for the next strip. It took a while and we sat right close next to each other, which felt a little odd. I felt like we ought to chat, but beyond basic pleasantries I wasn't sure what to say, and kind of wanted to stay focused on fencing. So I watched the DEs going on. I got to see most of Kyle Margolies' first DE, where he came back from being quite a bit behind to win. I think David and I took the strip Kyle had been on.

I stuck with my basic generally defensive plan of working distance, trying to get him to attack from too far, or to lure him too close. It worked quite well in the first period and I got a comfortable 6-2 lead. In the break Russ basically said to keep doing what I was doing. The second period went similarly, although he got a bit better. I was patient, having a nice lead, letting time run down. The period ended 13-7. This was a very comfortable place to be. In the third period I think I let my large lead turn into a bit more passivity than was wise, and he had definitely figured some things out. He caught up to perhaps 13-10, which began to worry me and maybe helped kick me into being more active. Luckily I had such a comfortable lead I was able to eventually finish it, 15-12.



My second DE was with Jack Umanos. Russ warned me beforehand that "the second DE is always the hardest". I'm still not sure this really makes sense. Maybe he was just trying to get me focused and primed to work hard. Jack and I started off somewhat even, but soon I fell behind, deeper and deeper. He was wily. I think my sister said "wiry". He was very good about slipping out of binds and making last moment disengages. He got several points up in the first period. In the breaks Russ suggested envelopments, saying I needed to take his blade around twice or he would just slip out. I managed a few points that way, but it was too little too late. By the third period I was way behind. My defensive strategy was not going to work. Jack was happy to fall into his own defensive tactics, waiting for me. I tried various things, looking for single lights, but they mostly failed. I lost 15-9. I felt like I might have been able to do a lot better if I could have fenced him again, having gotten a sense of his style. But it was too much to solve within 15 points.

But it was all good. As with vet40 I had made all my default goals: making the cut, winning my first DE, and ending up higher than my preliminary seed. This last wasn't too hard since my prelim seed was so low. And my finish result was a little lower than my post-pool seed (48 vs. 46). But all in all it was extremely fun.

I could go on and on about how much fun I had at Nationals in general, and maybe I'll add more to this later. I have some videos and photos to edit. But for now, gotta post.

PICS

Here's some pictures my sister took on her phone.

Ref checking gear, probably the first pool bout. Jeff Johnson fencing in the background:



Me and, I think that is Eugene Vinitsky, with the red socks:



Why am I attacking with a bent arm? Who knows. Maybe it's a feint? I'm not sure who I'm fencing here. Maybe Jonas, my last bout. I mostly fenced on the other end of the strip:



Just me:



The start of my first DE with David Mackenzie:




Another, up four points, nice:



This must be just before I won that first DE:



And apparently this is the winning touch. Looks a little awkward, but hey, nice timing, sis! I think I had attacked with a straighter arm, then let it fall so as not to skewer him as I came forward. That's my theory for the apparent weird form anyway:








2015 Nationals Vet40 Epee

2015 Nationals Vet40 Epee

http://usfencingresults.org/results/2014-2015/2015.06-JUN-SN/FTEvent_2015Jun27_V40ME.htm

(I've been sitting on this partially finished writeup for a month, time to finally get it done and up!)

My first time at Nationals, vet40 epee my first event. I got in the day before but was still feeling somewhat overwhelmed by the whole thing. The vet40 epee didn't begin until 2:00, so I had plenty of time to get to the venue and warm up. Almost too much time: Apparently there was a shortage of refs right then, so we had about an hour delay after being assigned to pools and strips. Most of us ended up doing a bit more warm up fencing in our strip pods while waiting.

We had all four strips in the F pod and three strips in E pod. I was in pool #4 on strip F4. John Comes and Aaron Page were also in the F pod, in different pools. It was nice to have some friends around. Shawn Dodge was watching and gave me advice and coaching during the pool. Jeff Lucas came and watched. Russ and Marshall had other fencers to coach but came by eventually. Marshall coached and cheered me in my first DE, Russ in my second. Others from WFA and MTFC, like Tobias, were around the pod. It was nice having friends watching. Sometimes I imagine I'd feel distracted or a little anxious with people watching—when I did div3 epee my mom and sister were watching too. It was nice to realize how it feels good, not distracting at all, to have friends watching. If anything it made me try harder and focus better.

I had a rough start in my pool, when it finally started. I lost the first three, which started to give me a sinking feeling. But then I won the second three, feeling better and better with each bout. I ended three and three with an indicator of exactly zero. Right in the middle, which for me was not bad at all, I think.

I made a point of not checking the ratings of anyone before fencing. Usually I do, but I've started to think it is not helpful for me to know. Too often I'll let the ratings influence the way I think bouts should go, or what I should do. About a week before Nationals I was talking with Davis Carvey and he suggested I totally ignore ratings. I already knew they don't really mean all that much and I ought to mostly ignore them, but his saying it so bluntly helped me realize that I do let them influence me, generally detrimentally.

So I went into my pool without a clue as to who had what rating. Oh, I had looked at the basic distribution of ratings of all the vet40 fencers before flying down. I knew there were a lot of A, B, and C fencers, just a few D and E fencers, and a fair number of Us. But by the time I was there and my pool was starting I had put such things completely out of mind. Only afterward, looking over the results, did I see that I beat an A15 fencer.

The results also showed me that my preliminary seeding was 39 out of 48. After the pools I was seeded 26th (tied with John Comes). In the final results I came in 26th. So I more than made my goals. Actually I hadn't set specific goals, but by default they were, in approximate order of difficulty, first to make the 80% cut, second to have a final result better than my preliminary seed, and third to win my first DE. Actually, if I had seeded one higher out of the pools I would have gotten a first round bye and faced someone hard. In theory getting a bye should have been as good as winning my first DE, but I was happy it went the way it did. Winning that first DE felt great, as I came back from several points behind. Getting a bye would not have felt nearly as good.

POOLS



I didn't take notes so don't have much of a play-by-play. A lot of stuff here, like the ratings, I did not know during the pool.

My first bout was with Lewis Wadsworth. Lewis and I came out of the pools with an equal number of wins and the same indicator. But he had 24 touches scored to my 23, so he seeded above me. He was rated C13. I put up a decent fight but lost 3-5. Then I fenced David Hitchcock and lost badly, 1-5. David swept our pool, winning all his bouts and getting a +14 indicator. Then I fenced Andrew Davis. A close bout, but I lost 4-5. Not bad, Andrew, a B15, did second best in our pool. I'm not sure, but I think he was the guy with a moustache painted on his mask.

So things were looking a bit grim, down zero and three. I had been watching the other guys and with Shawn Dodge's help had come up with some plans for some of them. And I began to feel more warmed up. Things went better from this point.

I fenced Arejas Uzgirs and did well, winning 5-2. I later learned, a bit to my surprise, that he is rated U. Then I had Tracy Coldwell. He seemed pretty good (and I later learned he is an A15 from Cardinal). But I had been watching him and had a plan of sorts. It was a tough bout but I managed to stay very focused, concentrating hard on "one touch at a time". I won 5-3, to my delight. I thought that was my last pool bout and was happy to have come out two and three instead of one and four. I thought that might well be the difference between making or failing to make the post-pool cut.

So I was surprised when I got called for another bout. Good thing I didn't wander away. A couple of the guys looks a little alike and I had gotten confused. My last bout was with Marc Kuritz. By this point I was feeling much more confident and on. I felt well in control of the bout and won 5-3. I later learned he was a C13.

So I came out of the pools feeling quite good. A rough start, then a couple wins and I thought it was over at two and three, which I was okay with. Then a surprise "extra" win, making me three and three, with an indicator of exactly zero. That felt extra good.

DIRECT ELIMINATION

My first DE was against Onno Van Eikema Hommes. I'm not sure exactly how the scoring went, but I think I started off down 1-3, then 3-6, with the first period ending at 4-6 (and being vets we were only going to ten points). Russ was coaching someone else so Marshall was my coach. During the first period he called out some helpful advice (like "you're leaning, stand straight!"), but it was mostly during the break that I was able to understand what he was getting at. He said I kept doing sixes and he was disengaging them, and that I should do eight instead. Keep "feinting" sixes if I wanted, Marshall said, but when he actually attacks try eight.

So I tried that and got at least a couple points with eights. I also got a nice point doing a strong upward beat and hand pick. That one felt good. I paid minimal attention to the points, knowing how quickly things can change. I noted that I had tied it at 7-7, then got up a point at 8-7. But I think I did a good job of staying focused on "one touch at a time". Once I was up a point I think Onno got concerned and made a less than ideal attack, letting me get to 9-7. Maybe I got him in eight that time, I can't remember exactly. Then I tried killing time, which was starting to run out, being defensive yet active. Eventually Onno fleched and I managed to make it into a double, to win 10-8.

Afterward people congratulated me on my "good comeback". I had been so focused on not thinking about the score but rather on each touch I hadn't really realized I had had a comeback. I mean, I was aware of the score but only in a minimal way. I'm taking that as a good sign.

I enjoyed taking the bout slip up to the big bout committee area, far larger and more official than any other tournament I had ever been to.

My second DE was with Keith Lichten, someone I had never heard of and knew nothing about. I saw that he was the 6th seed, to my 26th. A couple people told me he was good and somewhat like John Varney. Russ was there for this one, and he suggested beforehand to fence him "like Varney". I went in feeling very confident, even while knowing this guy was going to be tough. I was totally ready to give it my all.

Well, he got the first point with a flick to the top of my hand. It came out of nowhere as far as I could tell and landed perfectly right on my hand. My reaction was something along the lines of "oh, so this is how it's going to be?" Well, I kept with my basic plan of fast footwork, getting in and out, trying to draw attacks from too far, trying to "keep the score low" like I might with Varney, and so on. He picked me off over and over, mostly to shallow targets with lovely tight bladework, flicks, and such. By the end of the first period it was 2-8, yikes.

Russ's advice during the break was fun. He said at this point my only real hope was to "try crazy things". And that I might as well because if I tried being defensive he was just going to keep picking me off, and what fun is that? I was like, oh I can do crazy things alright. So shortly into the period I tried that high-low Dragonettti fleche. It didn't work, 2-9. I don't remember the last point, but it was something crazy and he scored, so I lost 2-10. After, Russ said it can feel better to go out fighting than just getting picked off, and he was totally right.

I was very happy with how things had gone. The pools, the first DE. Keith was extremely good, and I didn't mind losing to him. When Marshall heard I had lost to Keith Lichten he said something about how he was surprised Keith had "only been 6th seed", and that he had once been on the National team, or something like that. Oh, and Keith ended up taking first place in this event. In fact, googling him right now I see he is a coach at East Bay Fencers and "ranks nationally and internationally". There's a 2012 video of him fencing Adam Watson in a round of 16 Div I NAC. And it looks like he's been fencing since the late 1980s, and doing very well at Div 1 levels since the 90s. And! Ha, looking at his Facebook page it says "one mutual friend". Bo Lawler, go figure. MIT connection. Bo connects so many disparate groups of friends it is starting to get absurd!